![]() |
Cornerstone Issue 8: September 28, 1998
Welcome to issue 8 of Cornerstone, an electronic
newsletter issued periodically by Core Competence.
Cornerstone reports on a wide range of networking topics
investigated by Core Competence. This issue, we depart from
our normal practice of providing URLs and abstracts of our
online works to report on a special project we performed in
collaboration with David Strom, Inc., investigating Internet appliances.
We are cross-posting David Strom's Web Informant Newsletter,
an online column in which David reports regularly on "all
matters web". We hope you enjoy "My Favorite Internet Appliance",
and encourage you to to subscribe to this newsletter at
   
http://strom.com/awards/pcn_jump.htm.
Dave & Lisa
You may not know what an Internet appliance is, but chances are you
could use one to simplify your computing life. Over the past year,
more than a dozen different vendors have sprung up to sell various
kinds of pre-packaged Internet servers.
Internet appliances come, for the most part, ready-to-use. Their
software comes pre-installed, and they require minimal configuration
to get them up and running. Most products are administered via a web
browser, making them fairly easy to setup and maintain. They are mostly
inexpensive, costing less than $2000. That is the good news. The bad
news is that different appliances offer overlapping features, making
choosing the right product difficult. And unlike kitchen or other
household appliances, it isn't immediately evident what these things
really do. When it comes time to make a toast or a roast, none of us
have any trouble distinguishing between a toaster and an oven for
the job.
But the problem is that Internet appliances can be used for a wide
variety of tasks and services, and each appliance combines a different
mix of services. The household equivalent would be if General Electric
started selling a combination dishwasher and carpet cleaner.
The number of Internet appliances available fall into roughly six
different categories: file servers (which provide simple shared
network disk storage), web servers (which can range from relatively
stripped-down models to those than can handle more complex programming
and scripting tasks), eCommerce servers (which automate setting up web
storefronts and handling payments), Internet application servers (to
deliver email and news and addressing services), communications servers
(covering routers and both dial-in and dial-out to the Internet), and
security servers (covering filters, proxies and firewalls). That is a
pretty broad swatch of applications.
So, buying an Internet appliance isn't as simple as using one. If you
never saw a blender, you would be hard-pressed to choose the right
appliance for making milkshakes, or even know that there is such a
device. The same is true in the Internet appliance marketplace. First,
you need to know the right questions to ask to frame your requirements.
Then, you need to focus on the type of problem you are trying to solve.
And finally, you'll need to collect information on which products match
your needs. Some products are better suited to remote offices or small
business owners, while others are geared towards teleworkers, Internet
and eCommerce Service Providers or for use in branch offices of larger
corporations.
There is surprisingly little information on this subject, until now.
Having seen this information gap, I set out to do something about it.
Combining forces with Dave Piscitello and Lisa Phifer at Core Competence,
we wrote a 20 page report describing the market, enumerating the many
different situations and products available. To help fund the project,
we obtained four sponsoring vendors and review their products in detail:
Cobalt Microsystems' Qube 2700 Internet application and web appliance,
the Encanto e.go Commerce web and eCommerce appliance, the FlowPoint
2200 SDSL router, and the WebRamp 300e dial communications appliance.
Our report is available in several different ways: free from the web, a
nominal fee for a printed copy, or from the sponsors themselves. We
also wrote a feature based on the report for the December issue of Web
Builder magazine. And Dave and I will be demonstrating these four devices,
as well as talking about the overall market, at the upcoming Atlanta
Interop (our session is on Thursday, October 22 at 10 am). You can find
links to the vendors along with copies of our presentations and the
reports below.
   
http://www.corecom.com/ia |